Written for us
By Michaela Da Marco
In recent days, the penal court of Bulaq (central neighborhood of Cairo) announced
the sentence of Ibrahim Issa, six months imprisonment and a 20,000 pound fine
(approximately $2,600.00). Issa is a journalist and editor of the Egyptian independent
daily newspaper al-Dustar, founded and then quickly shut down by the authorities
in 1995 and finally reopened in 2005.

Ibrahim Issa was accused by the Egyptian Secretary of Homeland Security in September
2007 for publishing internationally and nationally "false information” that caused
a "disturbance to general security" and placed the “public interest in alarm".
In August 2006, Issa published an article on the grave health conditions of the
Egyptian president Muhammad Hosni Mubarak and a year later similar stories continued
to circulate via the internet and text messages. During the trial, the president
of Egypt’s central bank, the president of the Alexandria Stock Exchange, and their
economic experts, testified that the misinformations disseminated by Issa contributed
to creating an atmosphere of panic and led “foreign investors to withdraw 350
million dollars from the Egyptian stock market.” He was sentenced under Article
188 of the Egyptian Penal Code, which stipulates that those who publish false
news provoking negative reactions with bad repercussions for the state, shall
be imprisoned. The International Federation for Human Rights (Fidh) and the Egyptian
Organization for Human Rights (Eohr) condemned the sentence and the governmental
misuse of the judicial instrument to violate the freedom of the press. In 2007
alone, 11 journalists and 5 editors of daily newspapers where incarcerated.
Howaida Taha, Egyptian Al-Jazeera TV journalist, was sentenced to 6 months in
prison, and ordered to pay a fine of 20 thousand Egyptian pounds, for “possessing
and releasing false pictures regarding the internal situation in Egypt that could
undermine the dignity of the country.” In January, Al-Jazeera aired a two part
documentary produced by Taha. Waraa al –Shams (Beyond the Sun), depicts the physical
and psychological torture carried out every day in the Egyptian jails.

The court moreover accused Howaida of reporting scenes "contrary to the real
facts". On January 13, 2007 the documentary filmmaker was stopped at the Cairo
airport where officials seized 50 of her videotapes. The secretary of homeland
security declared that the videotapes contained reproduced scenes of torture filmed
in a studio with paid actors. Howaida, who had previously obtained the permission
from the Egyptian Ministry of the Interior to circulate the scenes, was released
on bail and returned to Doha to prepare the documentary. However, in February
of this year, they issued a warrant for her arrest.
"This is an unjust and vindictive verdict!” said the journalist after learning,
in Doha, the verdict of the tribunal. "In my country, unfortunately, the tribunals
are not independent", she concluded. After the announcement of the prison sentence,
Hussein Abdel-Ghani, head of the Cairo headquarters of Al-Jazeera expressed his
disappointment regarding the erosion of the freedom of expression in Egypt. “The
limits imposed on the freedom of expression in my country disturb me. Writers,
journalists, and bloggers are facing a period of crisis.”
In addition, he added “The cases of torture reported in Taha’s documentary are
not only documented in the reports of the Organization for Human Rights, but also
in those of the High Consulate for Human Rights. Those who maintain that the scenes
of torture depicted in the documentary undermine the image of the state, would
do better to use the same energy to put and end to these practices. It’s a fact
that it’s the torture itself that corrodes the image of the country, and not the
documentary that denounces it.

In the government's sight for years now has been Dr. Abd al-Hailm al Qandil.
Activist in the Kefaya opposition movement, journalist, editor of the weekly newspaper
al-Arabi and ex director of the daily newspaper al-Karama, he is best known as
the author of Did ar-Rais (Against the President), a collection of articles against
president Mubarak, edited in the independent editing house Merit (the only in
Egypt that publishes stories, poems and essays against the current regime.) In
2004, Qandil was arrested by the police, taken into the desert, beaten and left
there without clothes for an entire night. In August of 2007, he resigned from
the Karama editing staff. It’s rumored that in a telephone call from a government
board official to as-Sibahi, head of the daily paper, it was stated, "if Qandil
doesn’t step down, the paper will be closed". A few days later, Qandil tendered
his resignation stating: "To close the newspaper would be worse. Even though I
am worried, because now all the articles published have to be "in line with a
certain tone" and probably the newspaper will loose its ‘subversive vein’… I will
take advantage of this by dedicating myself completely to the reorganization of
the Kefaya movement". Last September, Qandil was one the journalists accused of
having "transmitted false information undermining the reputation of the country".
He was sentenced together with the aforementioned Ibrahim Issa, and Adel Hummada
of the weekly al-Fagr and Wael al-Abrashi, of the independent newspaper Sawt ah-Umma.
A lot of other examples could be cited. There is the impression that while the
censorship may on the one hand intimidate, it also generates the opposite reaction
of stirring the imagination and spirit. Some young Egyptians have started to publish
pieces extremely critical of the current regime. The economic crisis and the systematic
violation of human rights in the country, denounced daily by different organizations,
offer to these young journalists numerous starting points for their articles.
Nevertheless today, among the young Egyptians, interest in politics is very limited.
Most of them have “other interests”. In reality many are afraid. These “guerrillas
of the press’ ( as someone defined them) are still in the minority, but represent
the wishes of all that today, in Egypt, dream of a country free of the political
monopoly of a government , supported by the West, for more than 27 years.